My failure as a GFX Designer

[Brandon]

This is my first sig.

Please rate from 1/10.

 

[bigguy]

Whats wrong with that. Its better than the one I just made. I give it a 7. I like it.

 

[Brandon]

Really, its my first.

 

[bigguy]

With a bit of text in it it would look niice and for your first one its awesome.

 

[Brandon]

Yeah when I made this I screwed up Photoshop so I saved then deleted the psd and reset photoshop.

 

[bigguy]

I was playin with photoshop last night. I think in order to make somethin really good (for me at least) you need a couple hrs and a good tutorial, lol. I keep tryin though.

 

[Conor]

Yeah it takes time to get good with layers and such. Good brushes are always good to have too.

Great job man. 8/10.

 

[Colin]

^ I must disagree, brushing is whored. All you need is the X brush and maple leaf brush. Use them to smudge backgrounds etc. If you want a tut on it I can give links or make one

 

[moose]

Ehh, I wouldn't say whored. I would actually want to see a little more movement in the whole sig.

Colors not too bad, might be a little too green up at top left corner, but nothing big since this was your first. Impressive job as a first. Text effects not too bad either.

I remember my first time using PS. I was like.. man f* this, how do I resize my render..

I think you're on a really good start. Just try out a couple tutorials that show you different ways of using tools in photoshop and you'll be rolling on in no time.

 

[Colin]

oh and for how it looks. Its pretty good for your first time 4.5/10.
1. too large, try 360x100-120
2. background too plain
3. needs a border or a larger one, try 1-2 px
4. text is ok, but a tad too small

 

[SEÑOR]

for a first is amazing my first was terrible!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[|Born2Shoot|]

oh and for how it looks. Its pretty good for your first time 4.5/10.
1. too large, try 360x100-120
2. background too plain
3. needs a border or a larger one, try 1-2 px
4. text is ok, but a tad too small

I disagree,

this is his first sig and it looks nice . Maybe the 1st sig he has ever publiced...

So It's not bad and a 4.5 is too low for that....

I see upcoming talent

6/10

 

[deaddevil]

The sig was nice, i like the text and background, quite nice!