Rate My banner

[Kay]

I like making banners and here is one I just made...

 

[pulse__xx]

I rate it 5/10 couldn't you use more 3d effects?

 

[Statico]

A bit plain on the right hand side, and perhaps blur the top right edge of the picture of the players to make it blend in with the black background like the bottom does.

5/10 agreed

 

[TooSiKWiTIt]

i like it but why do you have that big black area, are you going to add something there.
if not, i understand, i often do that as well
8/10

 

[deaddevil]

Hummm 5/10.

 

[dino-m]

My rate 7/10!

 

[elforo]

withought that black area i would rate it 8/10, atleast add something completely random there to make it more interesting

 

[Phil]

You can see were the blue for the soccer render stops, you should make that fade to the black. If your making these in paint you should try photoshop for great banners.

 

[ƒorte]

5/10
not bad for paint, though. Just a little empty on the right.

 

[Jake]

i'd give you a 7/10 but i think the text should be a bit bigger and a different style if possible... also photoshop is so much easier to make banners with photosohp... also the top-right side was kinda dull, it was just all black, try putting some picture or something there.

 

[trev]

Nice banner i like it 7/10 would be much higher if like everyone els has said the black area had something els to fill the space.

 

[Alejandro]

It is kinda empty, yeah, but the effect on the players and the grass is good. 7.6/10

 

[Mani5]

it IS empty 6/10

the font is exact match (soo I boosted 1 point up)

 

[Kay]

Thanks guys for all your ratings and comments

 

[clareto]

Cool shading of the players, but it's so dark.

I Suggest you to play with some glows, speccialy the text "pro ev...."
also some of the traditional "ghost" effect to introduce the players .

IMSHO, 6.5/10