Halo 3, Bio Shock, Gear of War Call of Duty4?

[jondisco]

which one do you think takes the cake? what is your opinion on the three?
1)single player mode
2)multiplayer
3)graphics
4)overall who do you choose

 

[NSChan]

1) Bioshock
2) Halo 3
3) Bioshock
4) Bioshock

 

[GG-Xtreme]

From best to worst:
1) UT3
2) GoW
3) COD4
4) BioShock
...
99999) Halo 3

 

[unpixelatedgamers]

From best to worst:
1) UT3

Um, he didn't mention UT3 you know.

Anyway, I've only played two of them (Halo 3 and Gears of War) so I can't really comment on the others. But of those two:

1)single player mode - Halo 3.
4 Player online and lan co-op primarily. Plus vehicles! And lots of guns!

2)multiplayer - Halo 3
Larger community, better online matchmaking, more game modes. Twice as many players in a match. Vehicles!

3)graphics - Gears of War
Halo 3 looks quite pretty, but it simply can't match the unprecedented detail in Gears of War.

4)overall who do you choose - Halo 3.
Gears' single-player is even shorter than Halo 3s, and offers no room for exploration. Online co-op, spawn-editor Forge and greater range of game modes, seal the deal for me.

 

[mcdonalds1989]

Liked Halo 3 alot, was good and played with friends online and multiplayer is sweet, the single was good..

I play Call of Duty 4 now when I am on my xbox or playing NHL 08 with some buddies...

Other than that, I say Call of Duty now cause Halo 3 seems slowmo when you go back to Halo

 

[charlies]

Single Player: Bioshock, easily the best single-player, COD4 is also a great solo game, Halo 3 apparently has **** single player (haven't played it though) that's confusing and seems cobbled together

Multi Player: COD4 is great online and off, even though it just lost to Bioshock in my books, only downside is that Multi Player is switched off when you pirate it, so it loses points there, but it is still great

Graphics: Bioshock wins by half-a-point over COD4 because of it's great cut-scenes that have amazing details, cut-scenes aside, Bioshock and COD4 are equal.

Overall: Bioshock won the most so it goes to it

 

[Clinton]

Played a bit of Bioshock but didn't get around to wanting to finish it. I don't mess with Halo and CoD4 is excellent.

 

[DiiSwift]

Halo 3 for multiplayer.

Thats all I care about.

 

[alex88]

+rep for DiiSwift...

halo 3 takes the cake.. who cares about singleplayer anyway?

 

[pvideo]

1)BioShock
2)Halo 3
3)GoW
4)Halo 3

 

[Cowen]

Its too hard to decide between COD4 and Halo 3 for multiplayer, they are both awesome and thats the only category I care about...