Favicon Poll

[mwnivek]

Favicon1:

Favicon2:

Hey,

I just made my own favicons and want to know which you think look best, or if you have any suggestions.


Here is my site's main logo:

The 3D options (which I haven't done yet) would have some basic lighting/shading. Let me know if you have any tips for making them 3D.

Thanks!

 

[Daniel S]

I voted for favicon 1 because it is the same image as in your logo and looks professional.

 

[TechAsh]

Favicon 1 for the same reason as comphelp. The only problem is that it looks a bit pixelated.

 

[leafypiggy]

agree with all above. i dont think you should do a 3D render of it. it looks fine, other than the pixilization.

 

[Neurosylum]

Gotta go with the flow. Icon 1 looks better.

 

[JuniorD]

i personally think you should add more effects to them. (yes im the one guy who said other)

such as gradients. maybe you should fix the distortion also.

 

[Pi606]

Basically what everyone else said, Icon 1. Just Anti-Aliased.

 

[santiago_pl]

the 1st one.
Try to smooth it

 

[LHVWB]

I definetly think that favicon1 is the best, and as santiago_pl said, you should definetly try to make it smoother so that it isn't so pixilated.

 

[darthypoo]

I voted for favicon 1 because it's your logo and that's what people with remember and associate you with.

 

[zacheri]

I voted for favicon 1 also. Same reason, it's your logo =)

 

[souradipm]

I voted for favicon 2 3d because, well 3d looks nicer
favicon 2 looks better to me because favicon 1's top ring is too light for me, so i go with #2 even if it's not in ur logo

 

[mattura]

I also agree - icon 1, but please anti-alias it!

 

[Danfelbm]

I voted for Favicon 1... because its some more professional and y like your logo xDDD...

 

[stahn.universe]

Icon 1 if you smooth it. Icon 2 if you don't.