Re: RPG and Adventure games, do graphics or story and battle style matter most to you
It's definitally "the whole thing". Every aspect in single game has it's part, meaning that if something lacks, usually something boosts. Let's take an example: Crackdown 2 Demo didn't have best possible graphics, but controls and camera + playability brought points up. As another example, let us take an older title, lets say umh.. Doom 2 or Duke3D (both PC and X360). Graphics are totally something else than good, BUT, there's lots of things that makes those games worth playing. Popularity, reputation, history, controls, stories, coop... list can be continued as far as you can imagine.
In PC category, I'd give an examples that still is quite questionable. Guild Wars and World of Warcraft!! GW, the almighty WoW competitor. WoW's strength is that it's Warcraft, but playing it isn't free. Too bad I never found it as exciting as Guild Wars coz GW has a lot more interesting stories.
Seconds, GW is not too complicated with all the GUI buttons and only 8 slotted skillbar (against WoW's 100000000+ skills). Of course there's only some skills you use in certain places and you don't need to load another bar every time you need new build in WoW, but it's a lot easier to get your 8 skills for your build and save the template. Other way around, it's only few clicks and you have your another skill set ready to use.
Graphics in both these games aren't great, but there is many things that compensate with it. In WoW, sounds and world are amazing and you have miles to map there. In GW, there's great stories, it's not crowded too often, PvE and PvP are purely separated, coop playing requires skills and experience same way as WoW, but teams are limited to 8 in PvE and PvP, except few elite areas where you have 16 players and one PvP arena where you play against 2 other teams instead of one.
One of the most important things I've noted between these two games, is that Guild Wars IS NOT FULLY GRINDING after completion of the game(s) and that Guild Wars is FREE to play.