Which Design?

[Phil]

In my opinion your orignal piece catches the eye better. I could be wrong but I believe that people like a sleek easy look and what better then grey and black with a shine to it.

 

[leafypiggy]

the problem is that it is too compact. People appreciate a design that fills their screen rather than not being big.

 

[coolv1994]

I like the redesign because it looks cooler.