what do you think?

[galaxyAbstractor]

Did I succeed well in following this tutorial: http://www.tutorial9.net/photoshop/the-vista-window-effect/ ?

This one of the hardest and coolest thing I've ever done in photoshop

 

[diabolo]

it looks nice for the design, but there is just something about it that doesn't appeal to me. I'm not sure if its the proportion of the box or what..just somethings there

but as for execution it looks really nice!

 

[galaxyAbstractor]

it looks nice for the design, but there is just something about it that doesn't appeal to me. I'm not sure if its the proportion of the box or what..just somethings there

but as for execution it looks really nice!

I didn't do it exactly as the tutorial tho (rounded corners, size) because I did only need the top part lol.

 

[nightscream]

The border is quite good but the black rectangle isn't. Put some depth in it, to make it seem like it's inside the border and not above it.

 

[burner35]

It's good indeed, But It needed a more smoother look.

 

[galaxyAbstractor]

did some avatars for chris73's request:

 

[lordsofvine]

not bad, it looks good, nice job, i wish i could learn that too

 

[galaxyAbstractor]

not bad, it looks good, nice job, i wish i could learn that too

it is pretty easy if you do exactly as the tutorial says. Link to it is in the first post if you need it

 

[Jake]

Very nice, try putting a light glow behind the star to make it blend better instead of the black background... also the original looks a lot like a windows vista window (not exactly though) but it looks good.

 

[knights_templar]

I love those colours, reminds me of an aurora look a wee bit. You do need to watch your measurements though...

for example the left border is smaller in width than the right border. If you use photoshop you can use the slice tool to measure the pixels, thats how I do it.

Trust me, if the measurements are equal it does make a difference...

 

[brightwire]

For a window, it looks O.K.